BluefoxToday blog : April 2007

A suitable mortgage.

Now that the subprime woes are generating fat headlines across the land, a debate is roiling around what to do about it. One idea that has received a fair deal of attention is the loan suitability requirement. Which means that lenders can only put borrowers in loans that are suitable for them. That they are able to repay. Some consumer advocates also propose that the borrower should have the right to sue if there is any breach of this fiduciary duty. Hmmm.

Frankly, I do have deep reservations about a loan originator being called to make subjective judgments about which mortgage program best suits an applicant. That would translate into him taking the responsibility of making a financial decision for someone else. Just doesn't sound right. Would that potentially open the door to allegations of discrimination? Yes, indeed.

Let's go into it a little deeper. A professional loan officer normally strives to become a trusted adviser for the prospect. So, by looking at the credit report and the application he can form a decent picture where the customer is financially. This is pretty standard. Now the discussion is steered into the borrower's future plans regarding the house purchase or refinance and then, armed with a full package of information now in front him, he can suggest a couple of mortgage programs for consideration. He'd also take a moment to explain the various loan features and answer any questions. Isn't that his role?

If the loan officer follows the suitability doctrine, he would make that decision for the borrower based on what he knows and has been told. What if the borrower falls ill three years later, can't make the payments and defaults on the home loan? He could sue the lender for the breach of his fiduciary duty. What if there is a divorce and the same thing happens? Or the consumer just simply changes his future plans for the worse? The payments were made on time up until that point, the mortgage was deemed suitable, but all of sudden the loan is in dire peril and now the lender could be liable.

I can see the investors who are buying mortgage-backed securities reacting to any legislation like this with alarm. Liability could come knocking on their door, too. What would it do to the cost of mortgage funding? Increase it.


Provided by: 

Esko Kiuru
Mortgage, real estate and apartment industry analyst - syndicated mortgage, housing and property management blog
My cell: 702-499-1006

Comment balloon 9 commentsEsko Kiuru • April 28 2007 05:18PM
A suitable mortgage.
Now that the subprime woes are generating fat headlines across the land, a debate is roiling around what to do about it. One idea that has received a fair deal of attention is the loan suitability requirement. Which means that lenders can only put… more
Is it time to refinance?
It very well may be. The most urgent reason to do so is if the homeowner has an adjustable rate mortgage, or an ARM, and it's about to reset upward. That way the payments can be kept from changing too much or not at all. To cash out some of the… more
FICO score boost.
Mortgage lenders today are setting higher loan qualification standards for borrowers with weak credit files. Since they're facing mounting defaults in the subprime segment, they have to. Now there's another issue to contend with. When they study a… more
New mortgage product.
Good news at last. It took a while. The last several weeks have been tough. The real estate headlines just about everywhere have oozed with subprime troubles this and foreclosure that and home values are dropping and so on. Followed by long and dark… more
Housing sector key in energy conservation.
UNEP, United Nations Environment Program, sponsors the Sustainable Building and Construction Initiative, or SBCI, that recently issued an eye-opening report about global warming and what role the building industry plays in it. The sector alone… more
Las Vegas housing in the spotlight.
The annual Las Vegas Perspective took place yesterday. It's actually a report that discusses in detail economic, government, demographic, business and lifestyle issues in the valley. A thorough undertaking. It's put together by the Metropolitan… more
Mortgage foreclosure remedy.
Contrary to popular belief, mortgage lenders are totally opposed to foreclosing. If they have to do it, it'll usually cost them money. And who wants to lose money? Nobody. EMC Mortgage reports that on average it loses 40% of the value of a home loan… more
American Real Estate Partners sell Stratosphere.
AREP, controlled by Carl Icahn, agrees to sell their gaming operations in Nevada, most of which are in the Las Vegas valley. These are casinos it owned here, so that in itself is normal. The action in that arena is steady. Companies are being bought… more
Shared equity mortgage to the rescue.
Despite the recent softness in the real estate market, buying a home can be a stretch for many first-time buyers and young move-uppers. Prices are relatively high in most areas and lenders are getting fussy. Shared equity mortgage could be worth a… more
Vegas housing stats mixed.
Let's start with the good news. The numbers are in for March and what we see is that the prices in Southern Nevada are holding up rather well. The median new home price is down 3. 5% from March of last year, but for the first quarter it's up 4%, to.. more