BluefoxToday blog : Esko Kiuru

Curious strategic mortgage default legislation proposed

Washington has already come up with some unusual and at times confusing legislation during this enduring housing collapse to correct perceived deficiencies. HVCC – the Home Valuation Code of Conduct – addressing the alleged appraisal problems of the recent past is one. The new RESPA – Real Estate Settlement and Procedures Act – is another that has led to many complaints and questions from the mortgage and real estate industries and puzzles the consumer as well. More of the same could be forthcoming.

House Republicans presented a surprise rider at the end of an FHA-related debate the other day that would prohibit mortgage borrowers who engineer a strategic default while still able to make payments from getting any future government-sponsored loans. Basically meaning FHA, VA, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. This proposal passed on a voice vote without any dissent probably because everybody was in a hurry to exit town for the weekend.

What is bothersome about this idea is that it would single out mortgage recipients for supposedly being morally wrong and for that they shouldn’t be allowed to enjoy any government benefits. Businesses, including mortgage lenders, constantly pull off strategic defaults when it’s in their best economic interest and no one waves a red flag saying it’s misguided. Some of the biggest mortgage banks just got bailed out, for starters. They also find tax breaks and other government support very useful. To be fair about this, companies then should face the same restrictions upon strategic default as homeowners do.

Wall Street’s greasy fingerprints appear to be all over this strategic mortgage default provision. They are seemingly becoming more common as the real estate meltdown lingers on and the home loan banking interests want to send a warning signal to homeowners who are toying with the idea. Really bad things will happen should they do it.

But the whole thing reeks of a double standard. What’s good for a company should go for an underwater homeowner as well. Fortunately the idea is just taking its first baby steps and once people read the details and find out what it really means it may not go very far. Enforcement alone would be a chore. Besides, it also needs to pass the Senate.



Provided by: 

Esko Kiuru
Mortgage, real estate and apartment industry analyst - syndicated mortgage, housing and property management blog
My cell: 702-499-1006

Comment balloon 14 commentsEsko Kiuru • June 13 2010 10:33PM
Curious strategic mortgage default legislation proposed
Washington has already come up with some unusual and at times confusing legislation during this enduring housing collapse to correct perceived deficiencies. HVCC – the Home Valuation Code of Conduct – addressing the alleged appraisal problems of the… more
Rich presents some strong arguments here about the mortgage market chaos and what it means to homeowners in distress. Millions of people across the United States are in trouble. One of every four (4) homes has a problem. Some are there… more
Las Vegas single-family house prices hang in there - sales slide in…
Southern Nevada real estate statistics continue on an unsteady path, as they’ve been for the past several months. One sector could show a bit of sunshine peeking through while anther struggles with a curve heading in the wrong direction. But anyhow… more
Effective homeownership rate in Las Vegas perilously low, according…
Southern Nevada homeowners were dealt a hand in the real estate and mortgage tragedy for the ages that had very little chance of keeping them in the game for long Severe price erosion has yanked tens of thousands way underwater – a suddenly… more
Mortgage foreclosure protection bill advances in California - Nevada…
Homeowners in distress have encountered a myriad of challenges when trying to save their properties from foreclosure. Many have successfully navigated around all the different shoals and rocks strewn along the way. Others, far too many actually,… more
Summerlin catapulted Las Vegas to big leagues in master-planned…
Howard Hughes tinkered in a lot things in his lifetime, aided by his canny vision of where opportunities to make an impact lie. One of them was the future of a dusty desert gambling hub known for sweltering, dry summer days sitting in the southern… more
Home-grown mortgage modification making headway
Creativity is the spice of life in the mortgage loan modification business. When the bottom fell crashing out of the real estate market and homeowners began sliding in droves toward foreclosure, home loan providers at first just watched the carnage… more
Las Vegas CityCenter condominiums tough sell
Southern Nevada condo market still wallows in the Lehman moment, especially the high-rise luxury segment that occupies choice space for the most part on and around the Strip. Units are hard to sell because mortgage financing has dried up, sharp… more
The Fed could make billions on MBS - mortgage-backed securities
When the housing market began recently unraveling at warp speed and quickly lugged the overextended mortgage industry along with it things looked quite bleak for the U. S. economy. Housing, after all, is one of its major components and should it be… more
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac continue bleeding
The two large GSEs, or government sponsored enterprises, that provide much of the liquidity to the secondary mortgage market are trying to improve their still misbehaving portfolios. Their underwriting guidelines have been steadily getting stricter… more